BRICS Update – September 2023
We wouldn’t go as far as to call the recent BRICS summit a non-event, but the clarity many of us had been hoping for at the end of August has not yet emerged. The main feature of this year’s summit was to add additional countries – 14 members now in total with many more waiting in the wings.
Adding all of these countries at once would have been impractical – and difficult. However, it’s not the actual ‘official’ membership rolls that matter – it’s the spirit of the agreement behind the countries who have already entered – and those who will enter moving forward.
This trading / currency bloc has a largely singular purpose – to remove reliance on a weaponized US Dollar. While it’s true that many in the US and Europe don’t perceive the western financial system as a weapon, much of the rest of the world does. Our perceptions in this instance don’t matter. It is the perceptions of the growing BRICS bloc that matter. A secondary, but related, goal is to move towards multilateralism on a variety of fronts. We’re going to focus on the economic and financial aspects of this.
Simply put, these countries are tired of being told what to do. They’re tired of being told they have no self-determination. They’re tired of being sanctioned when they don’t do as the collective west wants. They’re tired of the colonialist French (just one example) taking natural resources while the people in the countries who provide these resources live in abject poverty. This is perhaps the most important takeaway of the big globalization movement in the 1990s and early 2000s – the goal was NEVER to raise the living standards in these countries, but merely to use whatever levers could be applied to get the resources from these countries for use by the ‘first world’ nations. Again, they’re tired of it. This alone is the primary fuel for the BRICS movement. They have united against a common enemy – the weaponized US Dollar, SWIFT, and the many other structures that have arisen from the USDollar’s hegemony.
Put in this particular light, it would make sense that BRICS would introduce some type of currency. We have always assumed that it would be gold-backed. Why? Another worthless paper currency isn’t going to have much appeal – if any. If there is to be a new currency regime, there must be something unique about it that provides it with the necessary credibility to function. For many years, we economists have felt gold-backing would provide that credibility.
However, the landscape has changed over the past several years and as such, we need to revisit our prior assumptions. Could the mere disdain for the USDollar and it’s financial system be enough to give even an unbacked new currency credibility? A few years ago, we’d have opined in the negative. Now? It seems possible that perhaps a backing isn’t really necessary. At least not at the outset. Countries are already cutting deals to exclude the dollar using national currencies – none of which are backed by gold or any other commodity money. The resource-rich countries might argue there’s an implied backing – extracting natural resources requires tremendous amounts of economic activity. Could that activity in and of itself be enough to provide credibility? Yes – because that’s what’s going on right now. Again, it comes down to perceptions. If these countries view national currencies as less risky than the USDollar system, then that’l how they’re going to behave.
Do the BRICS nations have enough gold to back a currency either now or in the future? Absolutely. This is some of the information we were hoping to get out of this year’s summit. What we did see is a prototype of a potential BRICS note. While the providence of the images we’ll show cannot be 100% verified at this time, the rolling out of a new currency is an event that must be chronicled and studied. What we lack at this point is the clarity of the actual mechanics of the currency. Some questions are:
Who will issue the currency?
What (if anything) will back the currency?
Will non-BRICS members be required to obtain the currency in order to trade with BRICS members? This is huge for countries like the US
If the currency eventually used is a ‘hard’ currency (with commodity backing), what will be the peg?
If the bloc decides on national currencies instead, how will exchange rates be determined?
If there IS a BRICS currency, will it trade against other currencies in global FOREX markets?
If the bloc is serious about making this work, then we can answer some of these questions now. We can certainly opine on what ‘should’ be done. However, given the fluid nature of the situation – and the fact that the world is already mired in another regional (proxy) war and several smaller ones, the situation on the ground is likely to change rapidly and the attendant amount of disinformation will certainly be present – as is the case anytime countries are at war.
It is also worth mentioning that the BRICS countries do no agree on many other matters. Some of the countries have trading alliances with NATO nations for example, while others do not. Again, the single point of focus thus far is to (at a minimum) decrease dependence on the USDollar and its hegemonic system. Surely there are some current and aspiring members that would love to see the Dollar disappear from the world stage. Others are simply looking for a stable and reliable alternative.
Instead of ad hominem attacks, the US and the collective west would do well to take a huge step back and look at WHY the BRICS alliance started and why it is growing. From our vantage point, the wounds the Dollar has sustained have been largely self-inflicted, which is consistent with economic and monetary history. We simply don’t learn from history. Or, worse yet, there is enough hubris involved that policymakers think they can do things so much better now than in the past. Again, history indicates otherwise.
